Dealing with 'What If?'

Dealing with ‘What If?’

by Joshua Sklar

  • Pin this page0
  • Share this on Google+0
  • 0

Too often I think I have lived my life with eyes fixed firmly on the rear view mirror; my mind locked on to the idea of what may have been if I knew now what I did not know then, or if things had worked out differently. We all have these days from time to time, days when we are lost in what could have been. Today is one of those days for me. It is May 21st and the day this feeling hits me the most every year.

You see, twelve years ago on May 21 my beautiful wife Anna gave birth to our second son, Caleb Joshua Freedom Sklar. We had been waiting excitedly for this moment, that is up until the day before when we found out we would be having a stillbirth — he had died in vitro. Rather than celebration, excitement, and all the wonders that come with childbirth, we were left to wonder, “What if?”  I found with no answers for why (there was no medical reason for him to die), I could only think about all the “whats” that could have been.

What would it have been like to have him with us? What would his favorite color be? What activities would he enjoy the most? What is my family going to look like now and how will they deal with it? All the ‘what if’ questions piled up. What if we had moved somewhere else? What if we had done something different? What if there was something we should have done that we missed that made this happen? What? What? What?

The next few days passed in a dizzying blur for us. Hospital, funeral home, church, cemetery — on and on the list went. There were places and events that demanded our attention. Decisions that needed to be made. But, in the back of our minds, all the what questions went unanswered.

A few days later, I remember climbing in the car and going for a drive. It was just me and God in that car and I let Him have it — both barrels. I laid out all the anger, the sense of abandonment I felt, and the pain that was tearing me apart. In Old Testament terms, I lamented. And when I had spewed up all that was inside me, all I could do was sit and weep. But, just like in the Old Testament when one would lament, God came to me and brought peace. There in the car I realized a simple truth that was enough for me at that moment. It was simply one of the many names for God: “I Am.”

When God told Moses to lead the people out of Israel in Exodus chapter 2, He instructed Moses to say to the people of Israel, “I Am who I Am. This is what you are to say to the Israelites. I Am has sent me to you.” This truth was enough to help to carry me and my family through a terrible time – the truth that God was with us and His name is, “I Am” — a name in the present tense. The name He gave for Himself to Moses was not, “I Was”  — a name stuck in the past with all the hurts and what if’s. It was not, “I Will Be” — a name for the future with all its uncertainties and questions.  It was “I Am”  — a name that shows He is with you right now.

Somewhere in this process the realization came to me that I could not live a “what if” existence. I could not torment myself by coming up with different scenarios, or think about having a hand other than the one I had been dealt. I had a choice to make: move on with what I had, or be stuck because of what I had lost. But what I did know is that I had a God who was there, who would be with me in the valley of the shadow of death and would comfort us who mourn.

Twelve years have passed since that day. May 21st is always a different day for us now. It feels somber, quiet, and the sense of what could have been, should have been, is often times powerful. But while I used to look back and see what was gone, I now choose to try to look around and see what is here, what is now, and to dwell with the God who is “I Am.”

  • B. Parr

    Thank you for sharing this. My son, Isaac was also a stillborn in October of 2013 (also no medical reason for his death) so this really blessed me to read this-especially coming from someone who is a little further along down the road, so to speak. Thank you for the reminder of how important it is that we make a choice of where our focus will be-God’s grace or dwelling on what could have been. God bless!!
    B. Parr

    • Josh

      Hi B, Thanks for coming on Purpose City and sharing your story with us. It is a terrible thing to live through and it leaves many questions. As you continue to move forward it is great to hear that you are focusing on what God has for you. In the midst of the loss and confusion, I like the idea that our boys could be playing together right this moment…

  • Sarai N Joshua Chung

    The what ifs have been always been not just a question that i ask from time to time but almost an identity for me. An extremely rough childhood, a slew of horrible descions and failed attempts to change bad habits has left me feeling cursed thinking what if everything was diff espeacially me. I admit i stopped reading the bible completely, this website is my first attempt to nibble on the word of god and find hope and strength to change my thoughts and feelings. Help me pray.

    • Josh

      Hi and thanks for sharing where you are at. I am glad that you are still seeking God (I love the expression “nibble on the word of God”) and that you are looking for the hope and strength that He brings.
      Many of us are plagued with “What if?” in many different areas of our lives. But each one of these areas can be healed when we bring them to God. It sounds to me like your heart is already crying out to God for Him to move some mountains of pain and confusion in your life. That is a great prayer! When we realize that it is God who can move those mountains and we come to Him, we are ready for Him to work in us. Keep talking to Him, keep searching for Him, for He is ready to shower you with His love…